Chapters 8-10
Page: 64
Quote: "It was to be decided whether the result of my curiosity and lawless devices would cause the death of two of my fellow beings"
Although Mary Shelley did not physically create a monster, this emotion of guilt may also drag her down. She may feel like she failed as a wife and mother for the deaths of her family.
Page: 65
Quote: "But I do not pretend that my protestations should acquit me; I rest my innocence on a plain and simple explanation of the facts with have been adduced against me"
As Justine is trying to clear her reputation, Mary Shelley may internally be trying to clear her conscience as well.
Page: 66
Quote: "I beg permission to have a few witnesses examined concerning my character, and if their testimony shall not overweigh my supposed guilt, I must be condemned"
Shelley's experience may not mirror this scene, however, it most likely reflects the agitation of not being able to control her destiny and take control of her life.
Page: 67
Quote: "She was warmly attached to the child who is now dead and acted towards him like a most affectionate mother"
This could reflect Shelley's guilt and blame for not being able to protect her child from death.
Page: 67
Quote: "The tortures of the accused did not equal mine"
Shelley blames herself for the deaths in her family and must live on Earth with no one to console her and comfort her during such tragic times.
Page: 68
Quote: "But she had confessed"
Justine confessed to take control over her destiny. Likewise, Shelley must feel like her life is out of control and feels like she standing on thin ice herself.
Page: 69
Quote: "I soon shall see you again in heaven, where we shall all be happy"
Justine's confession and acceptance of death my reveal Shelley's unconscious hope of dying someday soon as well.
Page: 70
Quote: 'I wish,' cried she 'that I were to die with you'
Each character is a piece of Shelley and her struggles; Elizabeth represents her unconscious maternal guilt.
Page: 71
Quote: "I beheld those I loved spend vain sorrow upon the graves of William and Justine, the first hapless victims to my unhallowed arts"
Victor struggles with the guilt of not being there to protect these children from death as Mary Shelley regrets being unable to protect her own as well. Both feel like they failed to fulfill their duties.
Page: 72
Quote: "The blood flowed freely in my veins, but a weight of despair and remorse pressed on my heart which nothing could remove"
The "I" of Shelley talking. True emotions felt after the death of her babies and husband.
Page: 73
Quote: "I was now free"
Shelley's desire to free herself from darkness and death. She wants to live in happiness instead of despair.
Page: 73
Quote: "I was tempte to plunge into the silent lake that the waters might close over me and my calamities forever. But I was restrained when I thought of the heroic and suffering Elizabeth"
Like Victor, Shelley held back from suicide in respect to the rest of her family left because each of them lost someone as well.
Page: 73
Quote: "I had been the author of unalterable evils, and I lived in daily fear lest the monster whom I had created should penetrate new wickedness"
From this quote it seems as if the monster is compared to God. Shelley fears her future includes more tragedies.
Page: 74
Quote: "I no longer see the world and its works as they before appeared to me"
Shelley must have experienced the same train of thought when she wrote a science fiction novel during such times.
Page: 75
Quote: "And could not the tenderness of friendship, nor the beauty of Earth, nor of heaven, could redeem my soul from woe; the very accents of love were ineffectual"
While reading this I do not picture and Elizabeth, but Shelley and her husband. It seems as if this describes their relationship after they lost their babies.
Page: 80
Quote: "He bounded over the crevices in the ice, among which I had walked with caution"
This is the battle of Shelley's mind. The irrational monster and the rational Victor. Freud's theory of the id and ego.
Page: 81
Quote: "Begone, vile insect"
Shelley's inner turmoil. It's her struggle between her conscious and her self-hatred speaking.
Page: 81
Quote: "Have I not suffered enough, that you seek to increase my misery"
Shelley is torn. She unconsciously blames the deaths on herself and one side is trying to sooth her while the other is guilt ridden.
Page: 82
Quote: "I alone am irrevocably excluded. I was benevolent and good; misery made me a fiend"
Shelley's cry for happiness. She is alone and lost everything she had. The monser's depressions mirrors the grievances of her own heart.
Page: 83
Quote: "I weighed the various arguments that he had used and determined at least to listen to his tale"
Her rational consciousness acting to put aside her miseries to seek closure on the tragedies of her life is represented through this scene.
Thursday, December 11, 2008
Wednesday, December 10, 2008
Psychoanalytic Application of Shelley's Frankenstein
Psychoanalytical Application of Shelley’s Frankenstein
Mary Shelley lived a tragic life surrounded by death and despair. Not only did she lose her mother at a young age, but after fleeing from her father and step-mother, lost three of her four children at infancy and her beloved husband. It was a result of these tragic events that the motivation to write the novel, Frankenstein, originated. After studying the tragic life of Mary Shelley and analyzing her literature, one can discover a great amount of interpretation is necessary to understand the true meaning of the novel. Her novel is filled with events and characters that reflect her subconsciously. Psychoanalysts view her book as proof to their theories about the struggle between the unconscious and conscious thoughts of the dual human mind.
The most obvious connection between Shelley and her novel is the played out events of Victor Frankenstein’s life in comparison to her own. Shelley lost her entire family to various deaths where Victor’s entire family and loved ones were killed off. Both lost their mother at a young age which reflects Shelley’s desire for a mother figure in her life. Victor’s father never remarried unconsciously showing readers she did not approve of her fathers remarriage to her careless step mother. Throughout her novel, it is apparent that Victor blames the death of his loved ones on his selfish ambition to create life through science. With so much stress presented on this theme, a reader may assume that Shelley feels responsible for the deaths in her life as well. She obviously did not create a monster to murder her family, however, she may feel there was more she could have done as a mother, wife, and daughter to protect her family. No doubt Shelley was struggling internally as the battles of her conscious are reflected through Victor and his monster.
The monster and Victor play a massive role in the revelation of Mary Shelley’s conscious. The characters show her battle between her conscious and unconscious state of mind. Clearly the monster is the irrational side and Victor is the rational part of her mind. The monster trots around Earth fiery with the rage for being isolated on Earth whereas Victor travels through life with silent, bitterness for his mistakes and consequences. It is unlikely that Mary Shelley intentionally constructed her novel to show such connections, but like Freud believes, we act unconsciously most of the time. She unknowingly engaged herself in writing a catharsis of her life.
Interestingly, Frankenstein was one of the first science fiction novels written during that time period. The era in which Shelley lived was that of the Victorian, romantic, and enlightened genres. Her desire to create a science fiction novel and replace the God’s greatest gift of life with science shows her lack of faith in religion. She unconsciously reveals her lack of faith through the course of events in Victor’s life. As a result of losing everything and everyone she loved, no doubt she would question the existence of a higher being and turn toward the factual life of science. When countless tragic events affect one person, it is hard to maintain a spiritual life which one can see through her literature.
With Mary Shelley nearly family-less and temporarily faithless as well, what keeps her from committing the ultimate sin of suicide? She unconsciously answers this question in her novel as well. After the conviction of young Justine for the murder of William, Victor questions his actions and his life. In the midst of considering this escape, he thinks of his beloved family left on Earth and disregards his selfish thought. Putting ourselves in Mary Shelley’s shoes while she was writing Frankenstein, she had lost most of her family, but not all. One child remained alive. If Mary Shelley committed suicide to rid herself of her miseries, she would place her child in a worse position than she was as he will have no mother, father, or siblings. Through this, Shelley succeeded in being the mother she was not for her other three children.
Mary Shelley may not have intended for her novel to be a mirror of her emotions and thoughts, however, as Sigmund Freud has said, humans are motivated by their unconscious. We as a race relate our inner turmoil to everything around us. By creating a science fiction novel full of tragic events and conflicting emotions, readers can see straight into the heart and mind of the authors like Shelley. If she had not had such a tragic and upsetting life, her novel would most likely have been another typical romance or Victorian style piece of literature. Through researching psychoanalytical criticisms, Shelley’s novel undoubtedly helps prove Freud’s theory that the human mind acts primarily through the unconscious.
Mary Shelley lived a tragic life surrounded by death and despair. Not only did she lose her mother at a young age, but after fleeing from her father and step-mother, lost three of her four children at infancy and her beloved husband. It was a result of these tragic events that the motivation to write the novel, Frankenstein, originated. After studying the tragic life of Mary Shelley and analyzing her literature, one can discover a great amount of interpretation is necessary to understand the true meaning of the novel. Her novel is filled with events and characters that reflect her subconsciously. Psychoanalysts view her book as proof to their theories about the struggle between the unconscious and conscious thoughts of the dual human mind.
The most obvious connection between Shelley and her novel is the played out events of Victor Frankenstein’s life in comparison to her own. Shelley lost her entire family to various deaths where Victor’s entire family and loved ones were killed off. Both lost their mother at a young age which reflects Shelley’s desire for a mother figure in her life. Victor’s father never remarried unconsciously showing readers she did not approve of her fathers remarriage to her careless step mother. Throughout her novel, it is apparent that Victor blames the death of his loved ones on his selfish ambition to create life through science. With so much stress presented on this theme, a reader may assume that Shelley feels responsible for the deaths in her life as well. She obviously did not create a monster to murder her family, however, she may feel there was more she could have done as a mother, wife, and daughter to protect her family. No doubt Shelley was struggling internally as the battles of her conscious are reflected through Victor and his monster.
The monster and Victor play a massive role in the revelation of Mary Shelley’s conscious. The characters show her battle between her conscious and unconscious state of mind. Clearly the monster is the irrational side and Victor is the rational part of her mind. The monster trots around Earth fiery with the rage for being isolated on Earth whereas Victor travels through life with silent, bitterness for his mistakes and consequences. It is unlikely that Mary Shelley intentionally constructed her novel to show such connections, but like Freud believes, we act unconsciously most of the time. She unknowingly engaged herself in writing a catharsis of her life.
Interestingly, Frankenstein was one of the first science fiction novels written during that time period. The era in which Shelley lived was that of the Victorian, romantic, and enlightened genres. Her desire to create a science fiction novel and replace the God’s greatest gift of life with science shows her lack of faith in religion. She unconsciously reveals her lack of faith through the course of events in Victor’s life. As a result of losing everything and everyone she loved, no doubt she would question the existence of a higher being and turn toward the factual life of science. When countless tragic events affect one person, it is hard to maintain a spiritual life which one can see through her literature.
With Mary Shelley nearly family-less and temporarily faithless as well, what keeps her from committing the ultimate sin of suicide? She unconsciously answers this question in her novel as well. After the conviction of young Justine for the murder of William, Victor questions his actions and his life. In the midst of considering this escape, he thinks of his beloved family left on Earth and disregards his selfish thought. Putting ourselves in Mary Shelley’s shoes while she was writing Frankenstein, she had lost most of her family, but not all. One child remained alive. If Mary Shelley committed suicide to rid herself of her miseries, she would place her child in a worse position than she was as he will have no mother, father, or siblings. Through this, Shelley succeeded in being the mother she was not for her other three children.
Mary Shelley may not have intended for her novel to be a mirror of her emotions and thoughts, however, as Sigmund Freud has said, humans are motivated by their unconscious. We as a race relate our inner turmoil to everything around us. By creating a science fiction novel full of tragic events and conflicting emotions, readers can see straight into the heart and mind of the authors like Shelley. If she had not had such a tragic and upsetting life, her novel would most likely have been another typical romance or Victorian style piece of literature. Through researching psychoanalytical criticisms, Shelley’s novel undoubtedly helps prove Freud’s theory that the human mind acts primarily through the unconscious.
Tuesday, December 9, 2008
Psychoanalytic Criticism Background
Psychoanalytic Criticism of FrankensteinPsychoanalysis can roughly be defined through the comparison between a literary novel and a dream. Both are fictional yet based on reality and must be interpreted to discover the true meaning that lies within. By explaining that “terrifying novels and nightmares affect us much in the same way, plunging us into an atmosphere that continues to cling, even after the last chapter has been read—or the alarm clock has sounded” Sigmund Freud constructed his famous psychoanalytical ideas. Fr
eud believes that it is natural to connect the effects of literature to the mental effect of a dream. Literature is a production of the unconscious mind with which dreams are also created. To understand psychoanalytic criticisms, one must be acquainted with Sigmund Freud’s ideas and theories. He believes that human ambition, from both men and women, derive from primarily the unconscious. He also believes there are two sides to the human mind: the rational, conscious “I” and the irrational, unconscious “it.” At one time or another, all human beings have acted as a result of ego, irrationality, unconscious desires, and social complexes. Some of these states of being are reflected in his other famous theory that assumes children compete with their parent of the same sex for the attention of their parent of the opposite sex. His theories may seem far-fetched and uncanny, however, Sigmund Freud is the epitome of psychoanalysis. Mary Shelley’s novel, Frankenstein, is an obvious target for a psychoanalytic
criticism once people realize the author lost her mother, husband, and three out of four of her babies. Her existence was surrounded by death and despair, as was the life of the protagonist in her novel, Victor Frankenstein. Critics feel her novel also reflected her complicated family life and the possibility of oedipal conflicts within her own relationships (Oedipal refers to the theory of child competition with a parent figure). In the novel, Victor Frankenstein produces a life which is believed to be the replacement of his dead mother. Likewise, these turn of events may reveal the inner hopes of Mary Shelley to bring a beloved back to life.
eud believes that it is natural to connect the effects of literature to the mental effect of a dream. Literature is a production of the unconscious mind with which dreams are also created. To understand psychoanalytic criticisms, one must be acquainted with Sigmund Freud’s ideas and theories. He believes that human ambition, from both men and women, derive from primarily the unconscious. He also believes there are two sides to the human mind: the rational, conscious “I” and the irrational, unconscious “it.” At one time or another, all human beings have acted as a result of ego, irrationality, unconscious desires, and social complexes. Some of these states of being are reflected in his other famous theory that assumes children compete with their parent of the same sex for the attention of their parent of the opposite sex. His theories may seem far-fetched and uncanny, however, Sigmund Freud is the epitome of psychoanalysis. Mary Shelley’s novel, Frankenstein, is an obvious target for a psychoanalytic
criticism once people realize the author lost her mother, husband, and three out of four of her babies. Her existence was surrounded by death and despair, as was the life of the protagonist in her novel, Victor Frankenstein. Critics feel her novel also reflected her complicated family life and the possibility of oedipal conflicts within her own relationships (Oedipal refers to the theory of child competition with a parent figure). In the novel, Victor Frankenstein produces a life which is believed to be the replacement of his dead mother. Likewise, these turn of events may reveal the inner hopes of Mary Shelley to bring a beloved back to life.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)